Homeworks academic service


A critical appraisal of a qualitative journal article nursing essay

  • This research article critique focuses on This is a journal Article;;;
  • Critical Appraisal of Research:

The researcher realizes current relationship between nursing staff and poor patient outcomes. The authors of Methods and Critical Appraisal for Evidence-Based Practice differentiate ground theory from other qualitative research methods by stating that ground theory focus on process. Thus, this research is done to discover what can change nursing practice to ensure better patient outcomes.

  1. The results have been depicted in easily comprehensible tabulated forms which describe the demographic details of the participants, mean values obtained for the three instruments under study and the correlational attributes within the three. Method The authors of Research.
  2. Although the ten participants were reluctant to being interviewed after the 10 week period in a taped conversation, they continued to meet monthly and agreed for the same after an elapse of one year.
  3. Although the ten participants were reluctant to being interviewed after the 10 week period in a taped conversation, they continued to meet monthly and agreed for the same after an elapse of one year.
  4. A comprehensive list of the determinants will subsequently be discussed. The author has described all instruments in detail as far as their historical origin and validity for this particular study are concerned.
  5. Hill 2003 refers to global integration as the A Rhetorical Analysis of Article in Medical Journal 1278 words - 5 pages in establishing prior knowledge and expertise of the authors.

Method The authors of Research: Kalisch analyzed social process among nurses who are divided by job title into focus groups. She properly use grounded theory method to discover the phenomenon and collect data for the stated purpose.

Critical Appraisal Of Qualitative Journal Article

However, it is unclear if the study followed the guidelines of the grounded theory method. Data Collection The description of data collection lacks details in Kalisch 2006.

A Critique of the Qualitative Research Essay

The data collection did include human experience which was the nursing staff. Furthermore, the author should included clues about questions that were asked and if anything collected from the interviews focused her study. Nor does the author give any indication that enough time was allowed for full understanding of the phenomenon. The author should have described data saturation as mentioned previously.

In the data analyses section of Kalisch 2006 the author mentioned grounded theory method was used for extraction of themes from the interviews. If the author gave the systematic process the study could be replicated.

This necessary information would allow wider application to other professions. Additionally, in the discussion section the author relates the findings to the literature review Kalisch, 2006, p. However, before application of these findings the reader should conduct more research and more analyses because Kalisch 2006 findings are not conclusive.

  1. In the data analyses section of Kalisch 2006 the author mentioned grounded theory method was used for extraction of themes from the interviews.
  2. Caring for self increased the ascent atop the mountain as it increased the level of what the nursing practitioners could give to their patients in terms of positivity. The abstract is a succinct summarization of the intention behind the research and explains the salient points of the inference obtained as a result.
  3. Implications for occupational nurses in particular have been discussed as the author believes that they are the pertinent link in inculcating self nurturance tendencies affecting career and life satisfaction of the employees working under their guidance.
  4. The discovery of grounded theory. Both studies have satisfied these criteria within the limits imposed by the apparently small sample sizes.

Also, the reader would have to do more literature review or even contact author if possible to gain more knowledge about her process of sampling, collection and analyses so the study can be repeated and validity of the findings can be affirmed. The landscape of qualitative research.

The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research.

How to cite this page

Journal of nursing care quality, 21 4306-13. Methods and critical appraisal for evidence based practice 8th ed. How to cite this page Choose cite format: