Homeworks academic service


A raisin in the sun compare and contrast essay

What can be more morally invalidating than enslavement? But what if enslavement is a combination of the two; an ultimate death spiral that captures the soul, debasing the heart and unhinging the brain? Set around the same time, the two plays depict a morally impervious capitalistic monster at its pinnacle in American history.

  • Set around the same time, the two plays depict a morally impervious capitalistic monster at its pinnacle in American history;
  • In conclusion, the movie was a better depiction to me because I am a visual person;
  • In the movie, Lena answers the phone when his company begins calling about his absence;
  • The scene in the drama is on a Saturday.

As protagonists Willy Loman and Walter Lee fight for social standing and economic prosperity, disputes and familial discord flourish, hopes and dreams evaporate, and immorality permeates the helpless and struggling families.

As Hansberry and Miller magnify the constant suffering, dissatisfaction, sacrifice, and false hopes and dreams associated with the American economic system, the morality of capitalism is redefined and the immorality of an individualistic society reestablished. And it is with this that playwrights Hansberry and Miller balance the notion of an evil capitalistic America, and the plays transform into a deeper study of family dynamics and morals in the midst of struggle and adversity.

The Youngers and Lomans are saddled with the stresses of economic lack.

Compare and Contrast Essay of Death of a Salesman and A Raisin in the Sun

Both families subsist on meager servile jobs, especially the Youngers who suffer an extremely prejudiced community. This pecuniary crater sparks extreme discontentedness.

A Raisin in the Sun Compare/Contrast Play/Film Essay

This implies, therefore, that Ruth identifies wealth as a vital characteristic. Even Mama, who most vociferously proclaims contentedness, dreams of a new house and understands that only money will provide the way for such a transition.

Moreover, as her main goal to become a doctor mandates that she have money, Beneatha relates to the familial ilk of materialism as well. Either plainly or subtly, all members of the Younger family are discontent.

  1. She is not a character at all in the movie version. Possibly the biggest difference between the drama and the movie in this scene involves duologue.
  2. What is the American dream? How to cite this page Choose cite format.
  3. How fast would you like to get it?

Their discontentedness leads to disunity, mutual animosity, and ultimately failure. Their failure to remain collected, failure to overcome in the midst of adversity, and failure to be content under the most disheartening circumstances reveals their lack of intestinal fortitude. This characteristic disposes of morality in favor of personal goals and aspirations.

  • The plot in the play is Linder tries to buy back the house from the Younger family;
  • Possibly the biggest difference between the drama and the movie in this scene besides involves duologue;
  • The scene in the drama is subsequently.

All in all, with the acute frustrations associated with a most terrible economic environment for African Americans and the financial hoi polloi, the Youngers fail to resist depression although their circumstances allow for nothing elseand while they eventually gain a house the means of their acquisition portray them as undeserving.

To start Death of a Salesman, discontentedness is overshadowed by pride, as Willy tries desperately to build himself up in the eyes of others. All the while, Happy lifts himself up, essentially trying to extenuate his failure.

Even though Happy obviously has very little experience he insists he be the boss. This then entices the Loman brothers to focus not on hard work and dedication in the application of oneself, but rather the popularity and publicity of their image.

Nevertheless, the guise of imminent success and pending glory vanishes once Biff fails to go to college and Howard fires Willy.

Raisin In The Sun Compare and Contrast

The void becomes filled with discontentedness and a cacophonous aura. Happy fuels the fire by maintaining his pride and, in all intents and purposes, ignores the maelstrom of problems surrounding his family. As tensions rage, familial discord magnifies. Everyone in the Loman family has angst for one another.

With the advent of their moribund state of being and dispositions towards each other, the Lomans fail to overcome. They fail to stay true to each other. They fail to stay true to reality. They fail to stay true to themselves.

  1. Some film techniques used in this scene are.
  2. However, perhaps herein lays the evidence of human preeminence, of human greatness. Their failure to remain collected, failure to overcome in the midst of adversity, and failure to be content under the most disheartening circumstances reveals their lack of intestinal fortitude.
  3. The duologue in the movie has some omissions from the original text. In the film, the plot is the same as the play.
  4. The setting in the play is on a Saturday, moving day, one week later. However, in the play version it is Ruth that answers the phone and Walter is laying in his bedroom and it is found out he has been issing from work for 3 days.

And they fail to stay true to what is really important—the nuclear family. The Loman failures are as much terrestrial as they are spiritual—meaning the spirit of the family. More than a Pecuniary Struggle: However, on a grander scale, they depict life at its core, the family and all its idiosyncrasies, the morality of humans, our thoughts, and actions; how struggles, economic or otherwise, transform family; how certain characteristics such as pride and discontentedness degrade family; and how, above all else, the ordinances of man define family.

The Capitalist Monster:

The origin of human morality—otherwise being the product of human instinct—remains a mystery. What makes something immoral but the mere fact that we deem it immoral?

If we disregard religion, where do we derive the dictates of our conduct? Perhaps laws regulate moral from immoral, but who regulates laws but man? And so if we assume that it is man who regulates laws that regulate man, the question now becomes simply why do we regulate in the ways that we do, why do we opt for monogamy over polygamy, why honesty over dishonesty, and so on and so forth. So what could have possibly precipitated, however random a force of nature it may be, for example, human ordinance for one spouse.

Surely, natural selection favors those with the most widespread genetic variation and therefore those that procreate most frequently?

  • Someone from the neighborhood, Mr;
  • Nevertheless, the guise of imminent success and pending glory vanishes once Biff fails to go to college and Howard fires Willy;
  • He is tormented by his lack of success and believes the money can help realize his dreams;
  • I also had compared Act Two, Scene 3, in the play and the film.

Sadly, there is no answer to this question. There is no explanation for human morality.

Compare and Contrast “A Raisin in the Sun.”

However, perhaps herein lays the evidence of human preeminence, of human greatness. Perhaps with this peculiarity identified we may begin to define who we are, and why.