Homeworks academic service


Compare and contrast shays rebellion with the whiskey rebellion

Would you like to merge this question into it? MERGE already exists as an alternate of this question.

  • Due to the war, there was massive debt throughout the United States;
  • Hamilton's high excise tax was hard on the lower classes;
  • The main outcome was hopes for solvingthe state's debt problems;
  • Many protest meetings were held,and a situation arose which was reminiscent of the opposition tothe Stamp Act of 1765, before the American Revolution.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it? MERGE exists and is an alternate of. They fled once they heard the forces were coming to stop them, most escaped to the woods safely but a few were shot and killed. This rebellion showed government that the articles of confederation did not work, the articles of confederation was a 'constitution' that created a very loose tie between the coloniesand led to the revising and editing of the articles.

The articles were actually thrown out and a whole new document, the constitution, took its place. Whiskey Rebellion was when the government put a tax on all whiskey and other alcoholic drinks made or shipped to the US.

Since most farmers drank alcohol they were furious and revolted. This was shortly after the constitution and new government went into action and when Washington sent his troops and they arrived quickly, it proved to Americans the new government would act quickly in times of crisis.

What was the Whiskey Rebellion?

The Whiskey Rebellion was a citizen revolt against a 1791 tax onwhiskey. The reaction to the 1794 uprising in Pennsylvaniademonstrated the determination of the US to enforce Federal laws.

The militias of several states, under the personal command ofPresident George Washington, were used to end the insurrection. The tax on whiskey was bitterly and fiercely opposed by thesettlers on the frontier from the day it was passed. Westernfarmers considered it to be both unfair and discriminatory, sincethey had traditionally converted their excess grain into liquor.

Since the nature of the tax affected those who sold the whiskey, itdirectly affected many farmers. Many protest meetings were held,and a situation arose which was reminiscent of the opposition tothe Stamp Act of 1765, before the American Revolution. Severalgroups were formed in opposition to the tax, and refused to pay it.

Eventually the coercion of officials and private citizens promptedWashington to use military action. Shays' Rebellion Farmers were unable to pay the debts and taxes ontheir farms and they were being taken away by the courts.

DanielShays reasoned that his farm could not be taken away by the courtif there was no court. He raised a militia and led an uprising. They started burning down the courts in Western Massachusetts.

Theidea quickly spread and others began to do the same.

  • The reaction to the 1794 uprising in Pennsylvaniademonstrated the determination of the US to enforce Federal laws;
  • Why is shays rebellion remembered today?
  • The impact of Shays Rebellion was to make it clear that theArticles of Confederation had failed;
  • They fled once they heard the forces were coming to stop them, most escaped to the woods safely but a few were shot and killed;
  • Shays' Rebellion took place in 1786 in Massachusetts due topost-war depression, economic problems, lack of hard currency, andharsh government policies.

At the timethe states had very little federal backing and were unable to dealwith crisis such as this on their own. The federal government hadno authority to step in and help them under the Articles of theConfederation.

This event was a major factor in the creation of theConstitution. When was the whiskey rebellion? The rebellion started in on July 17, 1794 when a US marshal was sent to serve papers on avoiders of the federal tax was put on the producers of whiskey.

It ended in October of that same year when federal troops were sent in. The Whiskey Rebellion After the war, in precisely 1791, the people in charge found out that they were horribly in debt. So Alexander Hamilton bugged and bugged George Washington to make a tax on distilled drinks and spirits, such as whiskey.

He justified it as "more as a measure of social discipline than as a source of revenue. They held protest meetings incessantly; they considered it unfair and discriminatory.

After all, they had made the whiskey from their OWN grain. By 1794, tension was mounting and Washington decided to create some order.

Whiskey vs Shays' Rebellion--Reading Analysis, Questions and PowerPoint

So he sent a militia of 12, 700 to fight them of though no one was hurt. Finally, peace was established in 1797 when the following were charged for disrupting the peace: They had to pay fifteen shillings each.

Was shays rebellion led by Daniel shays? Yes, Daniel Shays led Shays' Rebellion. Because judges kept seizing farmer's land and putting the farmers in jail for not paying taxes.

What was Shays' Rebellion?

Why it was important for George Washington to put down the Whiskey Rebellion?

Shays' Rebellion The economy in the period following the American Revolution was extremely precarious. Due to the war, there was massive debt throughout the United States.

Foreign investors who aided the Patriots during the war started to call in their debts and Congress had to borrow money simply to pay accumulating interest. In addition, the Articles of Confederation ensured that unity in solving the economic crisis would be difficult. Some states had paid what was requested of them, while others could not make the minimum amount asked. At the local level, farmers were struggling.

They could not pay off their taxes or support their families. The economic hardship was exacerbated by the lack of commercial banks in the state, so people borrowed from each other in a pyramid of debt and credit. In 1785, English banking houses heavily involved with American trade began to call in debts as prices went down.

American merchants then called in their debts -- a chain reaction that went all the way to the bottom: The government that collected the farmers taxes was controlled by creditor and commercial interests and would not grant reprieve to the struggling farmers. The farmers petitioned the state government for an extension on their payments and issuing of new paper money to pay debts and taxes.

However, the state government was not sympathetic to the farmers. Frustrated with the inability to pay their taxes and debts, much less support their families, Massachusetts farmers stepped outside the law to solve their problems. Like most rebellions, meetings stressed non-violence, but soon the angry mobs took action. The farmers prevented the county courts from sitting, which were responsible for writs of property foreclosure. Farmers gathered around an old Revolutionary War veteran, Daniel Shays.

He too had fallen on hard times following the war and felt cheated that he wasn't compensated for his time in the Continental Army. Shays led 1,200 men to the federal arsenal at Springfield, attempting a full uprising on January 26, 1787. The state militia, financed by Eastern merchants fearing property damage, swept in and forced the "Shaysites" to retreat.

Though Shays' Rebellion failed, it paved the way for massive changes in US government. By then, it was understood that the Articles of Confederation had to be revised. After the American Revolution, there was a period of "Republican Extremism" that minimized government control, symbolized by the loose Articles of Confederation. But with Shays' Rebellion, a group eventually the Federalists formed calling for more governmental control and a new national Constitution.

Some historians believe "fundamentally altered the course of the United States' history. Shay's rebellion was an armed uprising in central and western Massachusetts, led by Daniel Shays.

It was in protest of high taxes and farm mortgages.

Why is shays rebellion important? It pointed out one the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and the national government was unable to help Massachusetts when the governor called for national troops to put down the "rebellion. The state legislature was composed mostly of merchants from Boston and other shipping towns and cities. In 1786, farmers assembled in conventions and demanded that their property tax be lowered.

To make up for the loss of revenue, they called for the abolition of aristocratic branches of the government in Boston. A Revolutionary War veteran named Daniel Shays led about 2,000 armed men against the Springfield arsenal.

The governor of Massachusetts asked for help from the national government but the government under the Articles was unable to act. The rebellion eventually collapsed but the problems continued. What impact did shays rebellion have? Shay's Rebellion was a response to difficult economic conditionsand fiscal pressures. The uprising showed that there was a need fora strong compare and contrast shays rebellion with the whiskey rebellion government.

What was the impact of shays rebellion? The impact of Shays Rebellion was to make it clear that theArticles of Confederation had failed. The Virginia Plan was alsoput into place seeking a strong central government. Why is shays rebellion remembered today?

Shay's rebellion is remembered today because it shocked Congress into calling a Constitutional Convention and also showed how well the Articles of Confederation worked. Was Shays Rebellion a tax revolt? War causes debt in most cases, and after the American Revolutionary Warthe new United States had to come up with a way to pay their debts to European countries.

One decision that left many people in significant trouble was to increase land taxes on farmers, and this created tremendous difficulties, especially between farmers and merchants.

There was inequity between the taxes farmers had to pay and the taxes merchants paid. Smaller farmers in the Eastern states couldn't meet their debts, leading to uprisings like the Shays' Rebellion. What was the outcome of shays rebellion? Shays' Rebellion took place in 1786 in Massachusetts due topost-war depression, economic problems, lack of hard currency, andharsh government policies. The main outcome was hopes for solvingthe state's debt problems.