Homeworks academic service


The need for capital punishment in america

The lethal injection room in Florida State Prison. From 1976 to July 1, 2018, there were 1,477 executions, of which 1,302 were by lethal injection, 158 by electrocution, 11 by gas inhalation, 3 by hanging, and 3 by firing squad. No state in the Northeast has conducted an execution since Connecticutnow abolitionist, in 2005.

Executions increased in frequency until 1999; 98 prisoners were executed that year.

  • Some states allow other methods than lethal injection, but only as secondary methods to be used merely at the request of the prisoner or if lethal injection is unavailable;
  • Consider also the case of Hank Skinner , currently on death row in Texas for the murder of his ex-girlfriend and her two sons;
  • The death penalty has been made to serve three kinds of purposes;
  • In general, scientific advances have undermined confidence in the reliability of eyewitness testimony and exposed flaws in the use of hair and fiber evidence;
  • Supporters of capital punishment object that these lives have to be weighed against the far more numerous innocent people whose lives can be saved if the murderers are deterred by the prospect of being executed;
  • Freedam's statistics looks at the percentage of all death penalty cases reversed, while the others look only at cases not reversed prior to habeas corpus review.

Since 1999, the number of executions has greatly decreased, and the 20 executions in 2016 were the fewest since 1991. It came up in the October 13, 1988, debate between the two presidential nominees George H. Bush and Michael Dukakiswhen Bernard Shawthe moderator of the debate, asked Dukakis, "Governor, if Kitty Dukakis [his wife] were raped and murdered, would you favor an irrevocable death penalty for the killer?

I don't see any evidence that it's a deterrent, and I think there are better and more effective ways to deal with violent crime. The bill was signed into law by President Bill Clintonwho had endorsed capital punishment during his 1992 presidential campaign. A study found that at least 34 of the 749 executions carried out in the U. The rate of these "botched executions" remained steady over the period.

Rees and again in 2015 Glossip v. Gross that lethal injection does not constitute cruel and unusual punishment. Mary Surratt was executed by hanging in 1865 after being convicted of co-conspiring to assassinate Abraham Lincoln.

She was the first black woman to be executed in the US since 1954. California has twenty-two; [60] New Hampshire has seven. In 2011, Texas raised this age from six to ten.

In California especially, an official commission proposed, in 2008, to reduce these factors to five multiple murders, torture murdermurder of a police officer, murder committed in jail, and murder related to another felony.

The following is a list of the 16 aggravating factors. Being convicted of a separate felony where death or life imprisonment was authorized prior to the aggravated murder. Being convicted of any separate violent felony prior to the aggravate murder. The offender put the lives of at least 1 or more other persons in danger of death during the commission of the crime.

Death Penalty Fast Facts

Offender committed the crime in an especially cruel, heinous, or depraved manner. Offender committed the crime for financial gain. Offender committed the crime for monetary gain. The murder the need for capital punishment in america premeditated, involved planning in order to be carried out, or the offender showed early signs of committing the crime, such as keeping a journal of the crime's details [68] and posting things on the Internet.

The victim would not have been able to defend themselves while being attacked. Offender was previously convicted of a federal drug offense. Offender was involved in a long-term business of selling drugs to minors. A high-ranking official was murdered, such as the President of the United Statesthe leader of another country, or a police officer. Offender was previously convicted of sexual assault or child rape.

During the crime's commission, the offender killed or tried to kill multiple people. Louisiana says that the ruling does not apply to "treason, espionage, terrorism, and drug kingpin activity, which are offenses against the State". Treasonespionage and large-scale drug trafficking are all capital crimes under federal law.

Treason is also punishable by death in six states Arkansas, California, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Missouri. Vermont still has a pre-Furman statute providing the death penalty for treason despite removing capital punishment for murder in 1965.

Legal process[ edit ] The legal administration of the death penalty in the United States typically involves five critical steps: Clemency, through which the Governor or President of the jurisdiction can unilaterally reduce or abrogate a death sentence, is an executive rather than judicial process. In the decades since Furmannew questions have emerged about whether or not prosecutorial arbitrariness has replaced sentencing arbitrariness. A study by Pepperdine University School of Law published in Temple Law Reviewsurveyed the decision-making process among prosecutors in various states.

The authors found that prosecutors' capital punishment filing decisions remain marked by local "idiosyncrasies", suggesting they are not in keeping with the spirit of the Supreme Court's directive. This means that "the very types of unfairness that the Supreme Court sought to eliminate" may still "infect capital cases". Wide prosecutorial discretion remains because of overly broad criteria.

California law, for example, has 22 "special circumstances", making nearly all premeditated murders potential capital cases. The only state which does not require a unanimous jury decision is Alabama. In Alabama, at least 10 jurors must concur. A retrial happens if the jury deadlocks.

  • But the procedure's popularity may lie more in how it protects witnesses and the public from discomfort and thus, preserve general support for the death penalty than protecting the condemned from excessive suffering;
  • The purpose of federal habeas corpus is to ensure that state courts, through the process of direct review and state collateral review, have done a reasonable job in protecting the prisoner's federal constitutional rights;
  • Of course, there are plenty of well-meaning people who are well aware of the problems outlined above and still genuinely and honestly support capital punishment.

If one of the judges on the panel opposes death, the defendant is sentenced to life imprisonment. However, the states differ on what happens if the penalty phase results in a hung jury: In the 22 other states, a hung jury results in a life sentenceeven if only one juror opposed death. Federal law also provides that the need for capital punishment in america. The first outcome is referred as the "true unanimity" rule, while the third has been criticized as the "single-juror veto" rule.

An appellate court examines the record of evidence presented in the trial court and the law that the lower court applied and decides whether the decision was legally sound or not. If the appellate court finds that no significant legal errors occurred in the capital sentencing hearing, the appellate court will affirm the judgment, or let the sentence stand.

These supplemental remedies are considered collateral review, that is, an avenue for upsetting judgments that have become otherwise final. If the case is a federal death penalty case, it proceeds immediately from direct review to federal habeas corpus. Although all states have some type of collateral review, the process varies widely from state to state.

State collateral review, though an important step in that it helps define the scope of subsequent review through federal habeas corpus, is rarely successful in and of itself.

Only around 6 percent of death sentences are overturned on state collateral review. Federal habeas corpus is a type of collateral review, and it is the only way that state prisoners may attack a death sentence in federal court other than petitions for certiorari to the United States Supreme Court after both direct review and state collateral review. The purpose of federal habeas corpus is to ensure that state courts, through the process of direct review and state collateral review, have done a reasonable job in protecting the prisoner's federal constitutional rights.

Prisoners may also use federal habeas corpus suits to bring forth new evidence that they are innocent of the crime, though to be a valid defense at this late stage in the process, evidence of innocence must be truly compelling. Freedam's statistics looks at the percentage of all death penalty cases reversed, while the others look only at cases not reversed prior to habeas corpus review.

A similar process is available for prisoners sentenced to death by the judgment of a federal court. In 2006, Congress conferred the determination of whether a state fulfilled the requirements to the U.

In recent times, however, prisoners have postponed execution through another avenue of federal litigation; the Civil Rights Act of 1871 — codified at 42 U. While the need for capital punishment in america appeals are normally limited to just one and automatically stay the execution of the death sentence, Section 1983 lawsuits are unlimited, but the petitioner will be granted a stay of execution only if the court believes he has a likelihood of success on the merits.

McDonough case, however, the United States Supreme Court approved the use of Section 1983 as a vehicle for challenging a state's method of execution as cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment. The theory is that a prisoner bringing such a challenge is not attacking directly his judgment of death, but rather the means by which that the judgment will be carried out. Therefore, the Supreme Court held in the Hill case that a prisoner can use Section 1983 rather than habeas corpus to bring the lawsuit.

Yet, as Clarence Hill 's own case shows, lower federal courts have often refused to hear suits challenging methods of execution on the ground that the prisoner brought the claim too late and only for the purposes of delay. Further, the Court's decision in Baze v. Reesupholding a lethal injection method used by many states, has narrowed the opportunity for relief through Section 1983.

Execution warrant[ edit ] While the execution warrant is issued by the governor in several states, in the vast majority it is a judicial order, issued by a judge or by the state supreme court at the request of the prosecution.

The warrant usually sets an execution day. Some states instead provide a longer period, such as a week or 10 days to carry out the execution. This is designated to avoid issuing a new warrant in case of a last-minute stay of execution that would be vacated only few days or few hours later.

Alabama has the highest per capita rate of death sentences. This is because Alabama was one of the few states that allowed judges to override a jury recommendation in favor of life imprisonment, a possibility it removed in March 2017. Californiawhich is the most populous state, has also the largest death row with over 700 inmates.

Wyomingwhich is the least populous state, has only one condemned man. But executions are more frequent and happen more quickly after sentencing in conservative states. Texaswhich is the second most populous state of the Union, carried out over 500 executions during the post-Furman era, more than a third of the national total.

California has carried out only 13 executions during the same period, and has carried out none since 2006. However, this is an under-representation relative to the proportion of convicted murderers; 52.

The states that have executed the most women are California, Texas and Florida. State uses only this method. State uses this method primarily but also has other methods.

  • Willingham was convicted because of forensic testimony from fire officials that arson experts call junk science;
  • Shortly after he was released from prison on assault charges, Hobbs was arrested in 2005 in Zion, Ill;
  • Shortly after he was released from prison on assault charges, Hobbs was arrested in 2005 in Zion, Ill.

State once used this method, but does not today. State once adopted this method, but dropped before its use. State has never adopted this method. Number of executions each year by the method used in the United States and the earlier colonies from 1608 to 2004.

Navigation menu

The adoption of electrocution caused a marked drop off in the number of hangings, which was used even less with the use of gas inhalation. Georgiamost states changed to lethal injection, leading to its rise. All 31 states with the death penalty provide lethal injection as the primary method of execution. Some states allow other methods than lethal injection, but only as secondary methods to be used merely at the request of the prisoner or if lethal injection is unavailable.

Capital punishment in the United States

Hospira, the only U.